바로가기메뉴

본문 바로가기 주메뉴 바로가기
 
 

logo

메뉴

의견개진 기대와 실제의 차이가 절차공정성지각에미치는 효과의 문화간 유사성과 차이점

The effects of expectation of voice on perception of procedural justice: Differences and similarities across cultures

초록

본 연구는 작업장면 의사결정과정에서 고용인들에게 의견개진 기회를 제공하는 것으로 인한 절차 공정성 지각에서의 효과가 조망이론이 제시하는 가치함수(Kahneman & Tversky, 1979)의 모양처럼 나타나는지 여부를 검증한 연구이다. 이를 위해서 시나리오식 상황자극재료를 사용하였고, 3개국 대학생 1,118명을 대상으로 하여 인터넷 실험조작을 통해 자료를 수집하였다. 주요 결과로는 첫째, 조망이론이 제시하는 것처럼, 의견개진 가치함수의 효과는 중립적 지점인 준거점에서 양 방향으로 처음 이탈하는 부분에서 절차 공정성 지각에 가장 큰 영향을 미쳤으며, 준거점으로부터 이격거리가 커지면서 단위량 변화 당 효과의 크기는 점차 감소하였다. 전체적으로 S자의 모양을 보였고, 곡선의 기울기는 이익영역보다는 손실영역에서 더 가파르게 나타났다. 둘째, 의견개진 가치함수의 모양은 한국, 미국, 싱가폴 등 3개국 모두에서 비슷한 모양을 보였다. 셋째, 이와 같이 가치함수의 모양은 비슷하지만, 문화권별로 준거점의 평균값은 상이하였다. 추가적인 연구 발견 및 인터넷-기반 자료수집 방법과 관련된 방법론적 함축점 및 공정성 연구자들을 위한 본 연구의 이론적인 함축점과 제한점 등이 논의되었다.

keywords
의견개진, 기대, 절차정의, 조망이론, 가치함수, 인터넷-기반, 준거점, Voice, Expectation, Procedural Justice, Prospect Theory, Value Function, Internet-based, Reference Point

Abstract

This three country study focuses on the value of employee voice in workplace decision making. Consistent with previous research, we show the voice value function fits the S-shaped curve associated with prospect theory (Kahneman & Tversky, 1979). Specifically, findings demonstrate that the value of voice of evaluated related to a neutral referent point. Initial increments away from this reference point have a strong impact on fairness perception, while later increments produce more marginal effects. In addition, the value function for losses is steeper than the value function for gains. These findings and methodological implications related to our internet-based data collection and use of international samples, as well as theoretical implications for fairness researchers are discussed.

keywords
의견개진, 기대, 절차정의, 조망이론, 가치함수, 인터넷-기반, 준거점, Voice, Expectation, Procedural Justice, Prospect Theory, Value Function, Internet-based, Reference Point

참고문헌

1.

Abbate,J, (1999) Inventing the Internet.Cambridge, MIT Press.

2.

Aiken, M., (1966) American Psychological Review, American Psychological Review

3.

Azar,B, (2000) A web of research:They're fun,they're fast,and they save money,but do Web experiments yield quality results, Monitor on Psychology

4.

Baldwin,T.T., (1991) The perils of participation:Effects of choice of training on trainee motivation and learning.Personnel, Personnel Psychology

5.

Brockner, J., (1990) The impact of layoffs on survivors: An organizational justice perspective. In Applied Social Psychology and Organizational settings, Erlbaum.

6.

Brockner, J., (1996) An integrative framework for explaining reactions to decisions: Interactive effects of outcomes and procedures, Psychological Bulletin

7.

Camerer, C. F., (1994) Violations of the betweenness axiom and nonlinearity in probability, Journal of Risk and Uncertainty

8.

Casey, J, (1994) Buyers' pricing behavior for risky alternatives: Encoding processes and reference reversals, Management Science

9.

Coalter,T., (1997) When voice matters: The influence of organizational traditions, sources of the tradition and historical outcomes on perceived fairness. Unpublished paper,

10.

Cronbach, L. J., (1970) How should we measure “change” ?or should we, Psychological Bulletin

11.

Doll, W. J., (1988) The measurement of end?user computing satisfaction, MIS Quarterly

12.

Earley, P. C., (1987) Procedural justice and participation in task selection: The role of control in mediating justice judgments, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology

13.

Edwards, J. R, (1991) Person?job fit: A conceptual integration, literature review, and methodological critique. , International review of industrial and organizational psychology

14.

Edwards, J. R, (1994) Regression analysis as an alternative to difference scores, Journal of Management

15.

Edwards, J. R, (1994) The study of congruence in organizational behavior research: Critique and proposed alternative, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes

16.

Edwards,J.R, (2002) Alternative to difference scores: Polynomial regression analysis and response surface methodology. In Measuring and analyzing behavior in organizations, Jossey-Bass.

17.

Folger, R, (1977) Distributive and procedural justice: Combined impact of “voice” and improvement on experienced inequity, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology

18.

Folger,R, (1986) Rethinking equity theory: A referent cognition model. In Justice in social relations, Plenum.

19.

Folger, R., (1998) Organizational justice and human resource management, Sage.

20.

Folger, R., (1983) Relative justification and procedural justification, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology

21.

Furby, L, (1986) Psychology and justice. In R. L. Cohen (Ed.), Justice: views from the social sciences, Plenum.

22.

Ghorbani, N., (2003) Individualist and collectivist values: Evidence of compatibility in Iran and the United States, Personality and Individual Differences

23.

Gonzalez, R., (1999) On the shape of the probability weighting function, Cognitive Psychology

24.

Gosling, S. D., (2004) Should we trust web?based studies? A comparative analysis of six preconceptions about Internet questionnaires, American Psychologist

25.

Greenberg, J, (1990) Organizational justice: Yesterday, today, and tomorrow, Journal of Management

26.

Heath, C., (1999) Goals as reference points, Cognitive Psychology

27.

Hewson,C.M.,Laurent,D.,& Vogel,C.M, (1996) Proper methodologies for psychological and sociological studies conducted via the Internet, Behavioral Research Methods Instruments & Computers

28.

Hofstede, G, (1984) The cultural relativity of the quality of life concept, The Academy of Management Review

29.

Hofstede, G, (1994) Forward. In Individualism and collectivism: Theory, method, and applications, Sage.

30.

Hunton, J. E., (1997) Effects of the user participation process and task meaningfulness on key information system outcomes, Management Science

31.

Hunton, J. E., (1996) ). A field experiment examining the effects of membership in voting majority and minority subgroups and the ameliorating effects of postdecision voice, Journal of Applied Psychology

32.

on, J. E., (1998) The value of voice in participative decision making, Journal of Applied Psychology

33.

Johns,G, (1981) Difference score measures of organizational behavior variables: A critique, Organizational Behavior and Human Performance

34.

Kahneman, D., (1979) Prospect theory: An analysis of decisions under risk, Econometrica

35.

Kahneman, D., (1982) The simulation heuristic. In Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases, Cambridge Univ.Press.

36.

Krantz, J. H., (2000) Validity of Web?based psychological research. In Psychological experiments on the Internet, Academic Press.

37.

Kras, E. S, (1981) Management in two cultures: Bridging the gap between U.S. and Mexican managers (rev. ed.). Yarmouth, ME: Intercultural.(1981). The psychology of social impact, American Psychologist

38.

Lind, E. A., (1990) In the eye of the beholder: Tort litigants' evaluations of their experiences in the civil justice system, Law and Society Review

39.

Lind, E. A., (1990) Voice, control and procedural justice: Instrumental and noninstrumental concerns in fairness judgments, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology

40.

Michalak, E. E., (1998) Guidelines for Internet research: An update, European Psychologist

41.

Naglieri, J. A., (2004) Psychological testing on the Internet: New problems, old issues, American Psychologist

42.

Price, K. H., (2001) Features of the value function for voice and their consistency across participants from four countries: Great Britain, Mexico, The Netherlands, and the United States, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes

43.

Robinson, W. S, (1950) Ecological correlations and the behavior of individuals, American Sociological Review

44.

Schmidt, W. C, (1997) World?Wide Web survey research: Benefits, potential problems, and solutions, Behavioral Research Methods Instruments & Computers

45.

Singelis, T. M., (1995) orizontal and vertical dimensions of individualism and collectivism: A theoretical and measurement refinement, Cross-Cultural Research

46.

Triandis, H. C, (1994) Culture and social behaivor, McGraw-Hill

47.

Tversky, A., (1992) Advances in prospect theory: Cumulative representations of uncertainty, Journal of Risk and Uncertainty

48.

U.S.Department of Commerce, (2002) A Nation Online: How Americans are expanding their use of the Internet, Author

49.

Van den Bos, K., (1996) The consistency rule and the voice effect: The influence of expectations on procedural fairness judgments and performance, European Journal of Social Psychology

50.

Watson, P. J., (1998) Irrational beliefs, individualism- collectivism, and adjustment, Personality and Individual Differences

51.

Wu, G., (1996) Curvature of the probability weighting function, Management Science

52.

Yamaguchi, S., (1995) Personality correlates and allocentric tendencies in individualistic and collectivistic cultures, Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology

53.

Zimmerman, D. W., (1982) Gain scores in research can be highly reliable, Journal of Educational Measurement

logo